Justice League # 1 Review

| | Comments (5)

http://www.aboutheroes.com/meta/images/JLA1-thumb.jpg

This Review Was Submitted by Knightwingbk
Writer: Brad Meltzer
Artists: Ed Benes & Sandra Hope

Well..... I'm torn. I liked this issue, but I did not get what I wanted from the issue. I wanted an issue with these three things:
1. The Big Three picking the League. -- Check.
2. The League being collected. -- Partial-Check.
3. The assembled League meeting for the first time. -- Nope!

So who is on the team? From reading the issue, and not looking at the Michael Turner Variant, I can tell you, the Big Three, Green Lantern, Black Canary, Arsenal, and... Red Tornado? We also see glimpses of Vixen and Black Lightning, although they are not fully collected or inducted. My big beef is that we did not see Arsenal or Black Canary being discussed by the Big Three, so how and why are they on the team? It's not explained here.

The writing is good, Meltzer writes good discussion from the Big Three when choosing the League, and he really made me like the Red Tornado, whom, before now, I did not care about. From a new reader's point of view, Meltzer makes me feel for the Red Tornado, but for older readers, it may have even more of an impact. Already we can see that Meltzer's arc is about the Red Tornado, and what happens to him in this issue. Some good moments throughout the issue, but not what I expected.

Ed Benes is as close as we will ever get to Jim Lee drawing the JLA. Needless to say, I like Jim Lee, so I can appreciate Ed Bene's similar art style, or maybe its his inker. Right. Lots to love in this issue, but from what issue zero was, I was expecting the three things I listed at the beginning. I give this issue a B. I'm patiently waiting the next issue to get numbers 2 and 3 on my list.

5 Comments

Steve K. said:

I really want to like this series, but I don't think Meltzer can pull it off. I want solid characters and classic battles.

Brent K. said:

The Covers on the issues are different than the image we have been seeing. Characters have been re-drawn, and some have switched places altogether.

I bought 2 copies, for each cover. First time ever! What a loser I am.

turk said:

I just can't get past Batman having 36" biceps. Christ, Benes...he's not the incredible Hulk.

Nick said:

Haven't read it yet but, did anybody notice Booster Gold standing up in this cover. What's with that?

Brent K. said:

Look again on the issue, Booster is not on either actual covers

Latest Podcast

Episode 98 - Maybe He Really Does Love You

It's a secret invasion of the About Heroes podcast! Is one of us a Skrull? Ben joins the regulars to help us figure it out. On this episode:

  • E-Mails from Jesse and Ray
  • Logan 2
  • Cable 2
  • Young X-Men 1
  • The Walking Dead 49
  • Amazing Spider-Man 555
  • Buffy the Vampire Slayer 13
  • Angel - After the Fall 6
  • Abe Sapien - The Drowning 3
  • Secret Invasion 1

Episode 98 - Maybe He Really Does Love You

Podcast Links

About Heroes at iTunes PodcastAlley.com Feeds

Feeds (RSS 2.0)

Call us

859-648-0108

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by EvilOmar published on August 24, 2006 7:45 AM.

Deadman # 1 Review was the previous entry in this blog.

Batman # 656 Review is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

9rules
Powered by Movable Type 4.1