
Review written by: Knightwingbk
This trade paper back collects SPAWN #1-8, 11-12. Issues 9-10 are missing I think because of copyright issues, they cross over into some other Image comics, and cannot be reprinted...
This was my first time reading Spawn comics. I had seen the movie, and have all 3 animated movies, so I'm a little familiar but this was really me jumping in, and well, lets just say I will be getting Volume 2 when it comes out in May.
If you're familiar with Spawn's film and animated adventures, the animated adventures follows the comics more closely. The movie gets some things from the comics, but it may draw more from the next volume as Jason Wynn only makes a brief appearence near the end of the trade. Since we all know Spawn's origins, the mystery surrounding it is not as powerfull as it may have been when the book first came out, but very little is presented to us in the first 8 issues. Also, don't expect to get Cogliostro in this trade to appear at all and say "These are your powers, here's how to use them, and this is what the war is about." We only find out about the war in the later issues, and Spawn discovers his powers one by one on instinct. This is a good tool for us as readers, as we relate more to Spawn as he ponders his powers and how to use them. In these ten issues, Spawn in a genuine human being. He was just raised from the dead, so he is bound to be very emotional. This is good because it allows us to form an attachment to the character.
These first 8 issues are a good introduction, and even the side characters, Sam & Twitch, and Wanda are reletively well-written. Of course this could be my bias by having seen the animated series, and hearing their animated voices in my head as I read the book. Each issue is reletively self contained, each has a plot, with beginning, middle and end. Only the Violater and Overtkill arcs have cliff-hangers, each being two issues a piece. It may be this self-contained setup that makes you feel that you get more of a story here. Rather than just one adventure, you get a couple, making this books $20.00 price tag well worth it. 10 issues hey, the Batman Hush trades will put you back 28 bucks for 12 issues!
My favorite stories were the one issue ones. The Billy Kincaid issue was enjoyable, as well as the issue where we see him in hell, becoming a hellspawn. I was shocked that I liked this issue because in the animated shows, they drew this storyline out for abour an hour and a half (or at least it felt that long) and if you've seen the episodes, they can get a little slow. When I read the story, it was nice because it accomplished everything that took an hour and a half in the show in 20 pages. I wish that Spawn episode could have been 20 minutes! Also issue #10 where Spawn visits his Grandmother is touching. Granny is blind but recognizes Spawn (or Al) by his voice, and knows he's a ghost. And even though Spawn has been to hell, Granny tells him that she thought he was a good soul and believes he is in heaven, and has been sent back for an important reason. This is a nice closure to the trade where Spawn has been mourning and lamenting for the past 9 issues, its nice to see our protagonist get a little pick-me-up before his next big conflict.
The art is good, if you like the Image style and even if you dont like it. I liked it, as an artist myself, as long as its detailed. I think that McFarlane's twisted and spindly style works for his character, and he illustrates all 10 issues collected here. Each artist needs to match the story they are telling, Detailed, Ivan Reis or Jiminez; collassal story and cast, George Perez; action adventure, Jim Lee; hard crime and mysteries, Micheal Lark; wierd charicatures and concepts, Todd McFarlane. Spawn, Hell, the Devil, Malbogia, Sam & Twitch, are all basically charicatures when you boil them down to it, so the art style does not conflict with the story and adds a little flair to it.
My two major complaints, Spawn should keep his mask on, and where are the two missing issues? Spawn's mask is part of the costume, so if he's wearing the costume, he should wear the mask, its synomymous. Spiderman, you think of the mask. Batman, you think of the mask. Spawn should be the same. I understand the point of taking off the mask to show he's burned, but him adventuring for a whole issue without it? A little wierd for me. The two missing issues are talked about in thought captions in issue 11, so they could've at least provided a little synopsis of them. If the Angela issue deals with the war between Heaven & Hell, then shouldn't it be summarized in some fashion?
Overall, as an introduction into the Spawn universe, a B- because it left a lot of mysteries, but the characters and the overall arc of the story was good enough to keep you wanting to check out Volume 2 (which comes out in May).