
Review was submitted by forum user Ray2007
Batman: Face the Face TPB
Writer: James Robinson
Artists: Leonard Kirk, Don Kramer
Publisher: DC Comics
I never thought I would actually say this about a Batman trade book, being a fan and all. But, the best compliment I could give this book is that I'm glad I checked this out of my local library this week, instead of buying it. I actually had to read the trade twice, and it wasn't because it was so good the first time.
First things first. This story takes place after the events of "Infinite Crisis" and "One Year Later". After the changes that occured in "Crisis", Batman was one of a number of heroes who took a year-long sabbatical, simply disappearing from sight in Gotham City with no warning, or explanation. Then, a year later, he returns, with no warning, and still no explanation. Robin had accompanied Batman on his leave, so who was left to look after Gotham? None other than a (yet again!) newly facially restored Harvey Dent...at Batman's request! It seems that with his face restored for the umpteenth time, Harvey has also managed to submerge the dark side of his personality...and actually does a good job of keeping order within Gotham.
Then, the murders start occurring. Murders occur everyday in Gotham, but these are special, because the victims are high-profile personalities such as KGBeast, Magpie and the Ventriloquist. And it looks like Harvey is to blame. Evidence at the scene of each murder points in his direction, or should I say to TWO FACE'S direction. But is the case as cut-and-dried as it appears to be?
Granted, I've been out of the loop with comics for a long time, and I've been recently re-familiarizing myself with my favorite characters, reading as many books (trades in particular) as I can to bring me back up to speed. So, in a sense, I'm coming back to Batman with fresh eyes. But when I finished this book, my first thought was, "Aside from the extraordinary step of Bruce Wayne wanting to legally adopt Tim Drake as his son, since Tim is now an orphan, was there ANY point to this story at all?" From other sources I've looked at about this story, this was meant to show a new direction for the Batman mythos and the Batman character. Yet to me, very little has changed.
Take the title: "Face the Face". Two "Faces" in the title. Get it? Does this drop a not so subtle hint as to what the core of this story is supposed to be about? Then, the latest restoration of Harvey's face. Come on, let's be honest with ourselves. How long is this restoration REALLY going to last? Do any of us WANT Harvey to be restored? Not if we want to maintain one of the most classic tragic villains in Batman's history. So, does anyone NOT think that eventually, he'll back to his dual self before long?
Next, we have characters like Jason Bard, a private eye, and Great White Shark, another villain locked up in Arkham Asylum, that were deux ex machinas that were totally unnecessary to the story. Why were they unnecessary? Because the story itself was told badly. Bard and Shark both represented to me elements of the story that were totally unbelievable. And in each case, it was based on a new characterization of Batman. Introducing new character traits is a tricky thing, and I felt that the writers were using a water bucket, when they really needed an eyedropper. Shark especially, is there to create an enormous irony in the story. But the irony only works if you can believe in the underlying causes.
In this case, Shark is behind the murders because he wants to be the supreme crime king of Gotham. But, Batman can't prove it, even though that's what all the evidence he's gathered suggests. So, Batman defends Harvey. And yet, sure enough, Harvey is back to his Two Face ways before long, because, his dark side was never suppressed to begin with.So, the irony is, though Harvey is innocent of the murders, he's too far gone (again!) to appreciate it!
For me, it would have been better if Harvey HAD committed the murders, but cleaned them up to make himself look innocent, making Batman TWICE the fool for defending him and choosing him to defend Gotham in the first place. That would have been a much better irony. And since when does Batman hire a second rate gumshoe to do some investigating for him, when he has the resources of people such as Robin, Oracle, Batgirl...or just HIMSELF? This is NOT the behavior of the World's Greatest Detective.
The story also concluded with Bruce Wayne proposing to Tim Drake that he become his son. Granted, throughout the story, we are shown Batman having that decision at the back of his mind, until he finally talks to Tim. But, unless you're Madonna or Angelina Jolie, adopting a child is a VERY big step in the lives of everyone concerned. Such a momentous decision should have been given more than a few panels worth of treatment. Maybe THIS should have been the story, where Batman is thinking about all the pros and cons of adopting Tim as his son, and maybe getting the reactions of Dick Grayson, Barbara, Alfred and others close to Bruce.
To be fair, there were good things about this book. The artwork was very concise, especially the way the Batmobile was drawn. The cover of the trade was very eye-catching and compelling. There was a good segment during a fight against the Scarecrow where Batman and Robin are both exposed to the Scarecrow's fear inducing gas, and have to confront demons, especially Tim, so soon after the deaths of his parents and Connor Kent, whom he had befriended during "Infinite Crisis". And much of the dialogue in certain scenes was actually good.
The problem is, like in film, good dialogue scenes and great production values mean little if the story you're telling is bad. And unfortunately, they did little to make this one a keeper.
C-